Loading...
BYH to those who make socialism a dirty word. You do know that Social Security and Medicare are examples of socialism....

Secrecy law forces family to fight for video

Bailey.jpg.jpg

A Nash County patrol car sits at the scene of an officer-involved shooting on Feb. 9 in the 1200 block of Maudis Road in Bailey.

Loading…

Tuesday, March 12, 2019

Body-worn cameras were supposed to serve as a silent witness in confrontations between police and civilians and usher in a new era of public confidence in law enforcement through transparency.

As a Thursday hearing in Nash County Superior Court shows, we’re failing on both fronts.

Spectators’ gasps filled the courtroom when Reid Sasser, the State Bureau of Investigation’s assistant special agent-in-charge, testified that only one of at least eight body cameras and dashboard cameras was recording Feb. 9 when Nash deputies shot and killed 28-year-old Johnathan Ramirez, who was accused of wielding a rifle and refusing to relinquish it.

Members of Ramirez’s family and a media coalition of three Raleigh-area television stations had filed petitions for the video’s release, a step required by a 2016 law that exempts police footage from the N.C. Public Records Act. Superior Court Judge Quentin Sumner came down on the side of disclosure. But questions about how the deadly shooting unfolded may remain unanswered.

The three deputies who were involved in the shooting and are on administrative leave while the SBI completes its review — Sgt. John Winstead, Deputy Stan Ricks and Detective Taylor Neal — turned on their body cameras after Ramirez was shot, Sasser testified. Their recordings likely preserved the incident’s aftermath but cannot corroborate Sheriff Keith Stone’s claim that Ramirez was holding a gun.

Sasser said another deputy at the scene had a body camera on during the shooting, and footage from that camera released on Sunday left questions unanswered. Not a single patrol car dash camera was rolling, Sasser told the court.

In a Feb. 11 press conference, Stone avoided making sweeping pronouncements about whether the shooting was justified, but in stressing the need for people to obey officers’ instructions, he seemed to imply Ramirez left deputies with no choice but to open fire.

That may well be true, but without the tale of the tape, will we ever know for certain?

As more law enforcement agencies began purchasing body cameras for their officers, state lawmakers passed House Bill 972, which made it unlawful to disclose police video without a court order and forced people to petition a judge for access.

Supporters of that law might say the system worked, as Judge Sumner ultimately ordered the video released. Indeed, Sumner made the right call and deserves credit for siding with the public’s right to know. But Ramirez’s grieving relatives had to clear a high hurdle in order to seek answers.

They hired a lawyer to argue their petition, and media outlets WRAL, WNCN and WTVD retained separate counsel. Attorneys seeking disclosure faced opposition from District Attorney Robert Evans’ office and lawyers representing the Nash County Sheriff’s Office.

Deputies work for the public, and the video they record should be public property. Instead, citizens who want to monitor deputies’ work have to pay attorneys to ask permission. As taxpayers, they’re also indirectly picking up the tab for prosecutors and law enforcement agencies to argue against their interests. That’s an outrageous, bizarre and broken system.

Sunday marked the beginning of Sunshine Week, a national initiative to raise awareness of public records and open meetings laws and champion the cause of open government. When it comes to disclosure of police bodycam and dashcam video, North Carolina remains stubbornly in the dark. It’s time to let some sunlight in.

Law enforcement footage should be reclassified as a public record. In cases where releasing the video might compromise an investigation, judges can still order the tapes withheld. Reversing the law’s current presumption of access would better serve the public without jeopardizing officers’ ability to solve cases.

Depictions of public servants doing their jobs shouldn’t be a state secret. We call on the General Assembly to fulfill bodycams’ long-touted promise of transparency by making this footage available to the public.

The Wilson Times

Loading…

Humans of Greenville

@HumansofGville

Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Editorials

March 19, 2019

The indictment of dozens of wealthy parents, including several Hollywood actresses and business leaders, along with the top college athletic coaches they allegedly bribed, tells a shocking story of corruption and deception in college admissions. If the charges are true, these privileged but…

College Admissions Bribery

March 19, 2019

There is no other way to put this: Arming teachers in North Carolina classrooms is as bone-headed an idea this year as it was last year. And the year before.

Small wonder a number of public school teachers have expressed fierce opposition to a pair of bills in the General Assembly that would do…

021019teachers05

March 16, 2019

To recklessly throw around claims of voting fraud is to play a dangerous game that could do lasting harm to our democracy.

Yet politicians from the White House to the local level are indulging in that game more and more. Social media and casual conversation cheer them on.

NPR pointed out a recent…

Election 2018-North Carolina

March 12, 2019

Body-worn cameras were supposed to serve as a silent witness in confrontations between police and civilians and usher in a new era of public confidence in law enforcement through transparency.

As a Thursday hearing in Nash County Superior Court shows, we’re failing on both fronts.…

Bailey.jpg.jpg

March 11, 2019

Gary Martin was exactly the kind of person that gun control background checks — a federal system now 25 years old — was designed to catch.

It failed. Again.

In Mississippi in 1994, Martin stabbed his girlfriend with a kitchen knife, beat her with a baseball bat, and warned “we are…

Gun Laws Domestic Abuse Q And A

March 05, 2019

Could the president known for his turbulent relationship with the media and strident criticism of negative news stories become a free-speech savior?

In a bombshell pledge during a two-hour speech at the Conservative Political Action Conference on Saturday, President Donald Trump said he’d put…

March 04, 2019

Placing police officers in more of North Carolina’s public schools could be a positive step toward increasing school safety — if it’s done the right way.

The school safety committee formed by Gov. Roy Cooper after the deadly school shooting in Parkland, Florida, last February has…

Gun Violence Cooper

March 02, 2019

Whether he’s a big believer in the Constitution or just terrified of a President Bernie Sanders with unchecked power, U.S. Sen. Thom Tillis got it right last week on President Trump’s so-called national emergency at the Mexican border.

North Carolina’s junior senator split from…

Trump Border Security

March 01, 2019

The Washington Post

Former Trump lawyer Michael Cohen’s Wednesday hearing before the House Oversight Committee was explosive not for what was new — but, depressingly, what was not new to anyone watching this administration with clear eyes. The takeaway: President Trump is a liar with a…

Trump Lawyer Investigation Congress-2

February 27, 2019

Measles outbreaks continue to lacerate communities from coast to coast, and there’s absolutely no reason for it. The latest involve dozens of new cases in New York and in Clark County, Washington, across the Columbia River from Portland.

These shouldn’t be happening. The highly…

061214measles1_1.jpg
80 stories in Editorials. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 8
        Next Page»   Last Page»