I got the surprise of my life when people were complaining about a DR editorial. You mean the BYH column is not the...

Judge orders new hearing in 1994 murder


The medical examiner that studied Dontae Sharpe's case, M.G.F Gilliand, appeared on the stand during the Motion for Appropriate Release of Dontae Sharpe at the Pitt County Courthouse on May 17.


By Tyler Stocks
The Daily Reflector

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

A Wake County judge has ruled that new evidence can be considered in a 1994 murder that sent a man to prison for a crime he says he didn’t commit.

Wake County judge Bryan Collins ordered a hearing to be held in August for Dontae Sharpe, Pitt County Assistant District Attorney Valerie Pearce said Tuesday when asked for an update on the case. Collins has been appointed to hear the case because of conflicts with local judges.

Sharpe, 44, was convicted in 1995 in the shooting death of George Radcliffe, 33. Radcliffe was found dead in a small Mazda pickup truck about 9:15 p.m. on Feb. 11, 1994.

Sharpe’s attorney, Theresa Newman, said in a May 17 hearing that the truck crashed in a vacant lot at the corner of Sheppard and West Sixth Street, an area in Greenville known for drug activity at the time.

Medical examiner Dr. Mary Gilliland testified at trial about the side-to-side path of the bullet that killed Radcliffe. At the time she was unaware that the state’s principal witness had testified that Radcliffe was facing his killer, Gilliland testified on May 17.

“The new evidence is, now that she knows this, her opinion is that the state’s theory is medically and scientifically impossible,” Newman said.

Newman requested during the May hearing that the court grant a motion for relief to give Sharpe a new trial or overturn his conviction. Both Newman and Pearce presented briefs for Collins to consider.

Collins’ ruling, which has not yet been made public, says Gilliland’s testimony is indeed newly discovered evidence. Sharpe’s lawyers must prove six more factors before a motion for appropriate relief is granted, Pearce said. Those factors are:

  • The newly discovered evidence is probably true.
  • The evidence is material, competent and relevant.
  • Due diligence was used and proper means were employed to procure the testimony at trial.
  • The evidence is not merely cumulative or corroborative
  • The evidence does not merely tend to contradict, impeach or discredit the testimony of a former witness.
  • The evidence is of such a nature that a different result will probably be reached at a new trial.

“The law requires a seven-part test to determine whether there’s new evidence and whether that new evidence requires relief for the defendant,” Pearce said.

“The judge is ordering we hold a full evidentiary hearing to look at those other factors, in August,” she said. “If the judge finds these factors, he can set aside the defendant’s conviction and award him a new trial.”

Pearce said the state would have reassess all evidence and testimony to determine whether to proceed.

“That would be very difficult,” Pearce said.


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Crime and Rescue

August 23, 2019

A man convicted in a 1994 Greenville murder was freed after 24 years in prison Thursday when evidence that he did not commit the crime convinced a judge to order a new trial.

Because of the recanted testimony of a key witness, along with autopsy evidence showing her original testimony could not be…


August 22, 2019

A man convicted in a 1994 Greenville murder was freed after 24 years in prison Thursday when evidence that he did not commit the crime convinced a judge to order a new trial.

Because of the recanted testimony of a key witness, along with autopsy evidence showing her original testimony could not be…


August 22, 2019

The Greenville Police Department is investigating a reported armed robbery at a 10th Street laundry, according to a report issued Tuesday.

The report indicates $2,200 in cash was stolen from The Wash House, 2511 E. 10th St., during the incident, which took place about 12:12 p.m. Monday, according…

August 21, 2019

Someone stole more than $1,000 worth of assorted children’s clothes from Belk on Sunday, according to a Greenville Police Department report.

The theft occurred at the Greenville Mall at 714 S.E. Greenville Blvd about 1:17 p.m.

The items are valued at $1,334.50. The investigation is ongoing.…

August 21, 2019

A man on the run from authorities in Long Island, N.Y., broke into a car at a home in Bethel on Sunday night, the Pitt County Sheriff’s Office reported.

The break-in occurred about 8 p.m. at 6487 N.C. 11 North. A caller reporting the crime provided dispatchers with a description of the man.…


August 21, 2019

A Greenville woman faces charges of child abuse at an unlicensed day care she ran, the Pitt County Sheriff’s Office reported on Tuesday.

The sheriff’s office received a complaint on March 25 regarding an unlicensed day care facility being operated at 991 C E Senior Lane in Greenville.…


August 20, 2019

A Greenville man was jailed on charges he committed felony sex crimes involving a child who is under the age of 13, the Pitt County Sheriff's Office reported on Monday.

William Benjamin Stocks, 18, of Bridge Court is accused of committing the acts between June and July, according to news release…

William Benjamin Stocks.png

August 18, 2019

The following people were indicted on felony charges on June 24 and July 15, 2019, by a Pitt County grand jury. All information, including addresses, is from court records:

June 24 indictments:

Maurice Tommy Anderson Jr., 28, 1101 Grovemont Drive, Apt. A5, possession of firearm by felon for April…

August 18, 2019

Four men are jailed on $100,000 bonds after allegedly robbing a man and taking his wallet on Saturday morning, the East Carolina University Police Department reported.

Arrested were Tyshon Maleek Arnold, 18, of 1621 Vintage Road, Raleigh, Jacoby Kashen Cox, 18, of 307 E. Railroad St., Selma, Isaiah…


August 18, 2019

A Garner man charged with driving while impaired struck a ditch and a driveway, according to Pitt County court records.

The crash took place on Aug.7 at 5:45 p.m. near Hanrahan Road and Gaskins Road.

The driver, Fabian Jimenez-Salvador, 38, of 4501 Dewars Lane, was traveling Westbound on Hanrahan…

148 stories in Crime and Rescue. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 15
        Next Page»   Last Page»